Potatoes that literally melt-in-your-mouth

Melting potatoes look like they took all afternoon (they didn’t!), which is exactly why they’re my go-to side whenever we have people over. I first shared this melting potatoes recipe back in December 2022, and this updated version, with butter soaked into every bite, is my favorite yet.

London Lea holding a plate of garlic herb melting potatoes in her kitchen.

This update started with my Melting Sweet Potatoes, which have racked up over 10 million views and landed on hundreds of holiday tables these past two years. Justin came up with the idea to poke a few holes in each slice so the maple butter sauce soaks all the way in, and we knew we had to try it with these Yukon Golds.

I tested them with skins and without (loved them without!), with fresh herbs versus dried (fresh all the way, since dried work but don’t carry the same punch of flavor after cooking), and with regular versus reduced-sodium broth. Regular is my pick, but I’m a salty gal 😉 so go low-sodium if you’re watching your salt intake.

I won’t sugarcoat it, this recipe does require a bit of time and attention. You’ll need to flip the potatoes and add broth partway through.

But trust me, every step is worth it! And if you’re pressed for time, don’t worry, I’ve included some make-ahead tips below to make your life easier.

Want that same garlic herb butter on a crispier, fanned-out potato? Try my Hasselback Yukon Gold Potatoes.

Ingredients and Substitutions

For the exact measurements and detailed instructions, please see the recipe card below.

Labeled ingredients for melting potatoes in the oven: potatoes, garlic, rosemary and thyme, butter, chicken broth, avocado oil, salt, and pepper.
  • Yukon Gold potatoes: Pick potatoes that are about the same width so every slice cooks at the same pace, and save the ends you trim off for another recipe, like soup. Russets will work if that’s what you have, but the texture won’t be quite as good.
  • Salted butter: Melt all of it at once, then split it between the two rounds. I’ve made these quite a few times for my vegan friends with a vegan butter alternative (Miyoko’s is delicious!) and vegetable broth, and they turn out great.
  • Avocado oil: Any high-heat oil works here, like vegetable or light olive oil.
  • Garlic: I like to use a garlic press so it’s super finely minced. A knife works too, just mince it as fine as you can.
  • Fresh thyme and rosemary: Run your fingers down the thyme stems to strip the leaves, and chop the rosemary extra fine since the needles are tough. If your crew isn’t big on rosemary, go a little lighter on it (one reader did this for her family and loved them!).
  • Chicken broth: Carton chicken broth works great, but I’m a BIG fan of Better Than Bouillon stirred into hot water here, since the broth makes up so much of the sauce’s flavor (it’s saltier, so keep that in mind!). Either way, warm it up before it goes in the dish.
Wondering what's for dinner?
These 7 Simple Skillet Dinners make cooking on busy weeknights a delicious breeze! 😋

Step-by-step Instructions

Please see the recipe card below for the full instructions, ingredient amounts, and a printable recipe.

email this recipe!
Simply enter your email and get it sent to your inbox! You’ll also get the newest recipes from us every week.

Peel and slice.

Peel the potatoes, trim off the rounded ends, and cut them into thick rounds. You’ll get about two rounds per potato, with flat sides on both ends so they sit level and brown evenly.

Peeled Yukon Gold potatoes cut into thick rounds on a cutting board for melting potatoes.

Toss with the butter and oil.

Toss the slices with the first round of melted butter, the oil, and the seasoning until every side is coated.

Pro Tip: Don’t let the potatoes sit too long after you cut them and toss them in the salt- too much water will leach out and they won’t brown as nicely. Toss, then straight into the dish!

Arrange them flat-side down.

Lay the potatoes flat-side down in a single layer in a 9×13 baking dish, leaving a little space between each one, and pour any extra liquid from the bowl over the top. Then lift each potato so some of that oil gets underneath, which keeps them from sticking and gets the bottoms golden.

Roast and flip.

Roast until the bottoms are golden, then flip each one with tongs and roast until both cut sides are golden brown. They’re not done yet, but this is where those crispy edges come from.

Pro Tip: Why 425°F and avocado oil? The oven is hot enough to get the edges crispy and golden, and the avocado oil keeps the butter from burning before the potatoes are done.

Golden roasted potato rounds after flipping, ready for the garlic herb butter.

Make the garlic herb butter and poke.

While the potatoes roast, stir the rest of the melted butter together with the garlic and herbs. Once they’re flipped and golden, poke a few holes into the top of each potato with a fork, pressing about halfway down.

Pro Tip: Saving the garlic for this second round keeps it from burning in that first hot roast, so you get all the garlicky flavor without any bitterness.

Garlic press.

It saves SO much time!

Since it’s super important to get the garlic pretty small for this recipe, a garlic press like this one is a lifesaver!

It’s easy to use, finely minces the garlic, and does it in a fraction of the time as chopping it up by hand.

Butter, broth, and back in the oven.

Spoon the garlic herb butter over each potato, then pour the warm broth AROUND the potatoes, not over the tops. Bake until most of the broth has cooked off and a fork slides right into the centers, then spoon a little pan sauce over the top before serving.

Pro Tip: Pouring the broth around the potatoes keeps it from washing off all that garlic herb butter you just spooned on top.

Oops! What did I do wrong?

There’s still a lot of broth in the pan.
Put the dish back in the oven for a few more minutes until most of it cooks off, keeping an eye on the garlic. If the potatoes are already fork-tender, don’t stress, just spoon that extra broth over the top as sauce.

Next time, make sure you’re using a 9×13 dish, since a smaller one keeps the broth too deep to cook off.

My potatoes are stuck to the dish.
Give them a few more minutes in the oven, since a golden crust usually releases on its own. Then slide a thin, flat spatula under each one instead of prying with tongs.

They aren’t golden when it’s time to flip.
Leave them in a few more minutes before flipping, since that golden bottom is where the crispy edges come from. Next time, get them from the bowl into the dish right after salting, with a little space between each one.

The tops aren’t as crispy as I wanted.
Slide the dish under the broiler for 2-3 minutes at the very end, keeping a close eye on the garlic.

Tap stars to rate!

4.96 from 22 votes

Garlic Herb Melting Potatoes

These Garlic Herb Melting Potatoes are what happens when you poke a few holes in a crispy, golden Yukon Gold and let garlic herb butter melt right into the middle. The edges stay crisp, the centers go buttery and SO soft, and they’re my go-to side whenever I want to impress dinner guests.
A fork picks up one half of a melting potato with garlic herb butter sauce from a plate.
Yield 6 servings
Prep 15 minutes
Cook 1 hour
Total 1 hour 15 minutes
An image of an envelope sealed shut with the Evolving Table logo.

email this recipe!

Enter your email and we’ll send it directly to you.

Ingredients 

  • 2 ½ pounds Yukon Gold potatoes about 8 potatoes
  • 6 tablespoons salted butter melted
  • 2 tablespoons avocado oil
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • ¼ teaspoon black pepper
  • 4 garlic cloves finely minced
  • 1 teaspoon fresh thyme finely chopped
  • 1 teaspoon fresh rosemary finely chopped
  • 1 cup chicken broth warmed

Instructions 

  • Preheat the oven to 425°F with a rack in the middle position.
  • Peel the potatoes using a vegetable peeler. Trim off ½ inch from each end, then cut into 1-inch slices. Place the slices in a large bowl.
    2 ½ pounds Yukon Gold potatoes
  • In a large bowl, toss the potatoes with 2 tablespoons melted butter, avocado oil, salt, and black pepper until well coated. Arrange the potatoes flat-side down in a single layer in a 9 x 13-inch baking dish, leaving a little space between each one. If there is any extra liquid in the bowl, pour this over the potatoes. Lift each one up so some of the oil gets underneath the potatoes.
    6 tablespoons salted butter, 2 tablespoons avocado oil, 1 teaspoon salt, ¼ teaspoon black pepper
  • Bake for 15 minutes. Flip the potatoes using tongs and bake for another 15 minutes, or until golden on both cut sides.
  • While the potatoes bake, add the remaining 4 tablespoons melted butter, garlic, thyme, and rosemary to a small bowl. Stir to combine.
    6 tablespoons salted butter, 4 garlic cloves, 1 teaspoon fresh thyme, 1 teaspoon fresh rosemary
  • Using a fork, poke a few holes into the top of each potato, pressing in about halfway. Spoon the garlic herb butter over each potato, then pour the warmed chicken broth around the potatoes (not over the tops).
    1 cup chicken broth
  • Return to the oven for 20-30 minutes, or until most of the broth has cooked off and a fork slides easily into the centers.
  • Spoon some of the pan sauce over the potatoes and serve with additional fresh rosemary and thyme, if desired.
Last step! If you make this, please leave a review letting us know how it was!

Tap stars to rate!

4.96 from 22 votes

Video

Notes

Crispy potatoes: Get the potatoes into the dish right after salting them. Want them extra crispy? Broil for 2-3 minutes at the end (just watch the garlic!).
Baking dish: Using glass or porcelain? Make sure the broth is warm so the dish doesn’t crack. A metal pan works too and gives you a little more browning.
Swaps: Use ½ teaspoon dried thyme and ¼ teaspoon dried rosemary in place of fresh (crumble the rosemary between your fingers first). For vegan and dairy-free, use vegetable broth and a vegan butter alternative.
Make-ahead: Roast the potatoes through step 4, let them cool, then cover and refrigerate. When you’re ready to serve, warm them in a 425°F oven for a few minutes, then pick up with the garlic herb butter and broth in step 6.
Storage: Store leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4-5 days.
Reheating and freezing: Reheat in a 350°F oven for 10-15 minutes, or until warmed through. They’ll keep in the freezer for up to 1 month, but the texture won’t be quite the same once thawed since potatoes hold so much water.

Nutrition

Calories: 239kcal, Carbohydrates: 28g, Protein: 4g, Fat: 13g, Saturated Fat: 6g, Polyunsaturated Fat: 2g, Monounsaturated Fat: 5g, Trans Fat: 0.3g, Cholesterol: 22mg, Sodium: 537mg, Potassium: 668mg, Fiber: 4g, Sugar: 1g, Vitamin A: 316IU, Vitamin C: 32mg, Calcium: 40mg, Iron: 2mg

Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.

Made this recipe?Leave a comment below!

What to serve with melting potatoes

These go great with just about any main, but my favorite move is picking one that can share the oven. My Spatchcock Chicken and Bacon Wrapped Stuffed Pork Tenderloin both roast at 425°F, so everything comes out hot at the same time (the host in me LOVES this).

If the oven’s full, stick to the stovetop. Garlic Butter Steak Bites and Pork Chops with Apples and Onions both come together in a skillet, and Garlic Butter Cod is ready in about 15 minutes.

Since these potatoes are so rich, I like something fresh and green on the side. A Lemon Arugula Salad cuts right through all that butter, and Sautéed Green Beans or Air Fryer Brussels Sprouts stay out of the oven entirely.

For a Southern holiday spread, a pot of Southern Collard Greens with Bacon on the stove is never a bad idea.

More potato side dish recipes

Still on a potato kick? These crispy, golden favorites work just as well for a holiday crowd as they do on a regular weeknight.

Wondering what's for dinner?
These 7 Simple Skillet Dinners make cooking on busy weeknights a delicious breeze! 😋
4.96 from 22 votes (15 ratings without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Comments

  1. 5 stars
    My daughter Amy made these for Christmas and they were a hit! I had to ask her for the recipe because I’ve been craving them!

    1. I love that, Patty — thank you for sharing! Tell Amy she did a great job 😉 I’m so glad they were a hit at Christmas and even better that they were crave-worthy enough to track down the recipe!